A few reviews back I whinged about the predictability of the slasher genre...especially if the writers and directors are too lazy or talentless to inject something new into the mix. It's the same with the supernatural thriller...a horror sub-genre that's got a bit too predictable in recent years. For some reason it's a movie type that asian cinema does very well...it's just that when the style is translated into American movies, either in direct remakes (The Eye or Dark Water) or new stories (Mirrors, A Haunting In Conniticut) they're way too obvious as you can see the narrative cogs grinding away.
Such is the case with Orphan, a decently made, acted, and directed horror thriller which follows the same old pattern:-
1/ A wholesome American family.
2/ The family, or family member, has undergone, or is undergoing a traumatic experience (loss of a child, alcholism).
3/ A change in circumstances impacts the family (they adopt a young girl).
4/ Initially the change goes well, then strange things start to happen, which only the lead character will notice.
5/ The difference in opinion, regarding the strange occurances, will cause a rift in the family and call in to question the lead character's mental health.
6/ The lead character will investigate thier suspicions...first by microfiche (pre-1990's) or computer and then by travelling to see an 'expert' in their problem (a nun at the Orphanage/a Doctor at a mental insitution).
7/ Armed with their new knowledge, the hero will return to the family to battle the evil. If the 'expert' returns with them, they may likely not survive, unless a sequel looks promising.
8/ The family will again resist the lead character's attemps to convince them of the evil threat. However, once the hero has been delayed/incapacitated and the 'evil' finally fully revealed to them, they fight back too.
9/ Once the evil has been apparately vanquished, the evil will make a 'surprise' reappearance where the hero will have to make a near-sacraficial, and morally questionable, attempt to kill the evil once and for all.
That is Orphan. And many many others. The twist is cool, the tone mature, the direction solid and the cast capable. But a little extra something is required to make it stand apart from the crowd. The plain cheese and tomato pizza of supernatural-thrillers...if you will.